summaryrefslogtreecommitdiff
path: root/referee_response.md
AgeCommit message (Collapse)Author
2025-03-11Cleaned up and reorganized referee responseJaron Kent-Dobias
2025-03-10Changes addressing report #3, comment #3.2Jaron Kent-Dobias
Added a footnote discussing the intuition for interpreting a large Euler characteristic as a union manifold rather than a product manifold.
2025-03-10Changes addressing report #3, weakness #1.Jaron Kent-Dobias
Added a paragraph to the text discussing the content of previous work on this model.
2025-03-10Changes and comments addressing report #2Jaron Kent-Dobias
- Indicated which of the requested changes were made. - Modified the manuscript to indicated that the function H must be Morse, i.e., not have any degenerate stationary points.
2025-03-10Comment addressing report #2, fourth questionJaron Kent-Dobias
Discussed the interpretation of m given that the choice of x₀ is arbitrary to the value of the Euler characteristic.
2025-03-10Comment on report #2, third questionJaron Kent-Dobias
Discussed the relationship between the RSB instability in the Euler characteristic calculatian and that of equilibrium in the spherical spin glass and cost function cases.
2025-03-10Change addressing report #2, second questionJaron Kent-Dobias
Added a footnote discussing the comparison between our prediction of V_SAT and that made in the confluent tissues paper.
2025-03-10Comment addressing report #2, first question.Jaron Kent-Dobias
Addressed the contribution of complex-m_* saddle points when they exist.
2025-03-10Change addressing report #1, third comment/typoJaron Kent-Dobias
Added a sentence to the abstract emphasizing that the available DMFT data is not sufficient to resolve the open problem in asymptotic dynamics
2025-03-10Change addressing report #1, second comment/typoJaron Kent-Dobias
Added a footnote discussing the commutation of the limits N→∞ and α→0 or M=1.
2025-03-07Change addressing report #3, weakness 4.Jaron Kent-Dobias
Added paragraphs discussion the relationship between our conjecture and both different algorithms and different models.
2025-03-07Change addressing report #3, weakness 5.1.Jaron Kent-Dobias
Added a footnote explaining the use of subscript notation for the superdeterminant of an operator with more than two indicies.
2025-03-07Added text of referee reports to file for convenience.Jaron Kent-Dobias
2025-02-07Began to write referee responses.Jaron Kent-Dobias
2025-01-28Created file for referee responsesJaron Kent-Dobias